When a double murder conviction is overturned with the help of two citizen sleuths, investigative journalist Joe Sexton digs into the case.

While the Umbehrs point to a new person of interest, a surprise witness shifts the case in the prosecution’s favor.

The retrial ends in a hung jury, leading the state to try Dana for a third time. In an unexpected move, Dana dismisses her legal team and chooses to represent herself. The legal verdict brings finality to the case, but not necessarily the truth.